This Is Why Mecha Anime Is Hated (And Why It’s Not A Great Genre)

strelizia darling in the franxx wallpaper

Mecha is one of the oldest anime genres around. And the fact is – if it weren’t for Mecha, the industry wouldn’t have made it this far.

So we can say that much about the Mecha genre, historically.

Anyone who denies that doesn’t understand the influence it’s had on the industry’s success.

 

Speaking of history…

“Mecha” has been around since the late 1800’s. But during that time it was never an “anime“, let alone a Manga. But the idea of a “humanoid” robot did exist.

The first Mecha anime came to life in 1967 after being adapted into an anime series.

Later on (1970’s, 1980’s) we’ve had shows like Gundam, then Neon Genesis Evangelion which helped “boost” the genres popularity.

neon genesis evangelion

After all – Neon Genesis Evangelion is legendary for its success. Not just for robots, but the deeper message it lays out.

Since the 2000’s we’ve had Code Geass and Full Metal Panic. Followed by:

  • Gurren Lagann
  • Eureka Seven
  • Guilty Crown.

And others, including Darling In The Franxx by 2018.

But things have changed. Mecha isn’t what it used to be, and there’s a couple of reasons why.

Let’s talk about that!

mecha anime google search

 

This Is Why Mecha Is Disregarded:

 

1. Mecha is a BORING genre

gundam anime mecha 1

I can’t remember the last time someone recommended a “Mecha” anime for me to watch. Not EVER.

Can you? And if so – how many times were you “impressed” by what you saw?

Did it really blow you off your chair? I’m talking about since at least 2007-2010.

If you were born in the 90’s or 2000’s, chances are you dropped most of the Mecha shows you’ve watched.

It’s just not a fun genre to get into.

There’s a good reason: mecha is boring and stale like mouldy bread.

It’s been this way since anime shows like Gurren Lagann have aired.

  • It’s hard to make “Mecha” interesting beyond the robots and the typical themes you see.
  • It’s NOT as interesting as cooler genres like Shounen, Supernatural or even romance.
  • Teenagers (the main target audience of anime) don’t care about Mecha.
    • They’re more interested in Shounen, Isekai and comedy.
  • And it takes A LOT of hard work to produce a “quality” Mecha series.
  • Bigger budgets are necessary compared to something more simple like “slice of life”.

mecha anime meme

All of those things make “Mecha” a boring genre, in general.

Other than shows which have managed to keep Mecha alive these days, like:

  • Full Metal Panic.
  • Darling In The Franxx.
  • SSSS Gridman.
  • Gurren Lagann.
  • Code Geass.
  • And others I won’t mention…

The Mecha genre is DEAD. Or dying at least.

Teenagers and young adults aren’t “too” hyped about it for a reason.

I say that as someone who’s a part of that group, and someone who’s a BIG fan of Full Metal Panic.

And a big fan of Code Geass, Eureka Seven, and a few others I mentioned.

Read: 17 Of The Most Aesthetically Pleasing Anime

 

2. Times have changed

simon yoko and kamina 2

The modern day version of “Mecha” looks more like Gurren Lagann. And as one of the BIGGEST Mecha series we’ve seen, not to mention the most popular, it’s no surprise.

Gurren Lagann is influential, produced by the same studio behind Neon Genesis Evangelion.

Mecha shows like Gundam are a thing of the past. Times have changed.

  • Gurren Lagann evolved instead of sticking to the “traditional” style of Mecha.
  • And that’s why it’s probably the “coolest” Mecha anime, ever. Even non-fans can enjoy it.

Other Mecha of the past, and most in the present didn’t evolve with the times. And so – they’ve either become obsolete, or no one cares.

The same way most don’t care about the genre. Especially outside of Japan.

 

darling in the franxx mecha funny

Darling In The Franxx, whether you agree with it or not, is another Mecha that managed to keep the genre alive and evolve with the times.

“Alive” in the sense of bringing something new and exciting (if we ignore how it eventually turned out).

It might have stolen ideas from other Mecha in a way that’s blatant and enough to make you cringe, but it doesn’t change the point.

 

ssss gridman anime

And then there’s SSSS Gridman. Another mecha from 2018 that’s evolved with the times, as well.

This anime was received well, even if it’s not to the level of a “Code Geass” or Neon Genesis Evangelion.

It wasn’t enough to make Mecha an exciting genre again though.

That leads to my next point…

 

3. There aren’t many “masterpieces” or quality Mecha series

code geass c2 anime

Code Geass is an exception, because it’s still alive and kicking to this day. And of course – it’s considered a masterpiece in the anime INDUSTRY, not just in the “Mecha” genre.

It’s basically the Mecha version of “Death Note”. That’s why it’s so successful, interesting and clever with the way it handles itself.

 

full metal panic invisible victory screenshot

And Full Metal Panic is the ONLY Mecha series that’s managed to keep the genre alive, with multiple seasons for more than a decade.

It’s the most consistent Mecha anime, and it’s considered “great” among the sea of average Mecha shows.

Other than that, you have:

  • Gurren Lagann.
  • Eureka Seven.
  • Neon Genesis Evangelion.
  • Darling In The Franxx.

With the rest by 2019 standards being “debatable” in terms of quality (or mainstream success).

And obviously shows like Gundam and so many others, as I pointed out pretty much, are also quality series.

 

Mecha anime aren’t THAT popular or “successful”

You can’t point to many of them. Especially not the kind of successful Mecha shows that are universally accepted as “masterpieces” or “great” at the least.

There’s not a lot of creativity going on in this genre these days.

Creators reuse the same ideas, and even when they have good ideas – bringing them to fruition takes more work for a Mecha anime.

You can blame it on studios, their budgets, or the changing times. But “something” is standing in the way.

So until the Mecha genre is “reinvented” as a whole, the genre will continue to be:

  • A little boring.
  • Stale.
  • Uninteresting.
  • And unpopular with teenagers (especially).

So the hate (which is an exaggeration) won’t fade out anytime soon.

But who knows what the future holds for the Mecha genre.

 

Recommended:

25 Most Popular Anime Opening Theme Songs, According To YouTube

12 Of Greatest Anime Teachers You’ll Ever Meet

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
28 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments